
Latest news, views, comment, debate and useful links for students and alumni of the OU's law programme, and those with an interest in the legal system
Della Macdonald, in a dispute with another woman about who owned the cat, had planned to call her pet dog Hamish as a witness at Stornoway Sheriff Court on the Isle of Lewis.
Ms Macdonald claimed that when the court saw the affection the cat showed to Hamish in court, by snuggling up to him, it would be clear that the fought-over feline was hers.
The story began in 2010 when Nicola Dempster, a 19-year old hotel chef from the Western Isles off Scotland, purchased a kitten. She named him Smudge and cared affectionately for him but after six months he got lost and disappeared.
Ms Dempster searched all Smudge’s favourite haunts, posted a Facebook appeal and reported him missing to the Cats Protection Society. All of that was, though, to no avail.
Meanwhile, Smudge had turned up in a pitiful state outside the door of Della Macdonald. She nourished the black and white stray back to health and named him Oscar.
Later, Ms Dempster was euphoric to spot ‘Smudge’ at a roundabout and took him home.
Police were summoned to an explosive altercation when Ms Macdonald discovered where ‘Oscar’ had been taken.
Ms Macdonald’s legal action to reclaim ‘Oscar’ has now been discontinued as her star witness, Hamish the dog, has died and Ms Macdonald has become ill. The judge, Sheriff David Sutherland, decreed that the cat should remain with the original owner, Miss Dempster.
There are odd precedents of cases in which people have disputed the ownership of pets. In 2009 in Florida, two women fought a civil case over a 13-year old African Grey parrot.
For ten years, Angela Colicheski from Florida had loved her parrot Tequila. Then, one day he flew away over her garden fence. Three years later, she was sitting in a local Dunkin Donuts chatting to Sarita Lytell, whom she’d just met, when they started to talk about parrots. Lytell said she had one called Lucky that she had found three years earlier.
It became evident that he was the one Colicheski had lost but Lytell refused to return him. Tequila didn’t give sworn testimony but he did give squawk testimony. As soon as he was brought into court and saw his previous owner he emitted what witnesses said was a loud call of recognition. The court ruled he was the personal property of Ms Colicheski.
In 2006 in Argentina, in litigation between Jorge Machado and Rio Vega, the court ruled that a parrot called Pepo, which each man claimed was his, should be imprisoned until it uttered the name of its owner. Five days later, it squawked “Jorge” and sang the anthem of his owner’s favourite football team – San Lorenzo. Game over. Mr Vega lost.
Dogs have given testimony in earlier cases. In 1987, a border collie called Tetter appeared in a constructive dismissal case in Hampshire. It became relevant to know whether Tetter, who had been the subject of wrathful outbursts of the employer in the case, was well behaved. Tetter was called to give evidence and responded correctly when given such instructions as “sit” and “up”. His evidence assisted the claimant’s case.
In 1994, a robbery conviction of two men was secured with the assistance of Ben, an Alsatian tracker dog. On appeal, the Lord Chief Justice said that evidence about a dog’s behaviour was admissible provided jurors were warned that “the dog may not always be reliable and cannot be cross-examined.”
Professor Gary Slapper was Head of Law at The Open University 1997-2011. He is now Global Professor at New York University, and Director of New York University in London. He is also Visiting Professor of Law at the Open University. His latest book More Weird Cases is published by Wildy, Simmonds & Hill
You can follow him on Twitter @garyslapper
In his latest update Gary Slapper, Visiting Professor of Law at The Open University, looks at cases brought to court over the ownership of animals.... Litigation over the ownership of a cat has just ended because a key witness who was supposed to give evidence, a dog called Hamish, has died. Della Macdonald, in a dispute with another woman about who owned the cat, had ...
Professor Taylor (pictured), who was Associate Dean at Nottingham Business School, has a PhD in Economics and has directed research projects related to online teaching of Economics and the wider Social Sciences.
She is an Associate Director of the Economics Network at the University of Bristol, and has worked with the Economic and Social Research Council and the Higher Education Academy on addressing the identified skills deficit in quantitative methods across the Social Sciences.
Professor Taylor said she felt 'very privileged' to have joined the OU. For full OU news release click here.
Professor Rebecca Taylor, formerly of Nottingham Trent University, is the new Dean of The Open University Business and Law School. Professor Taylor (pictured), who was Associate Dean at Nottingham Business School, has a PhD in Economics and has directed research projects related to online teaching of Economics and the wider Social Sciences. She is an Associate Director of ...
Hi,
My first post.
Is there any case law on an injury claim whilst entering a performance area?
e.g. An individual decides to enter a Morris Dance street performance,then is 'surprised'when a DANCER steps backwards !! The person then falls & is injured.
Has he / she a claim? i.e. against the dancer? the street festival organisation? (the street is closed & subject to a premises license)?
Note this is the first such incident in 22 years.
COMMENT:
If a sports ground the claim / claimant would be thrown out !!!
Regards,Paul
Hi, My first post. Is there any case law on an injury claim whilst entering a performance area? e.g. An individual decides to enter a Morris Dance street performance,then is 'surprised'when a DANCER steps backwards !! The person then falls & is injured. Has he / she a claim? i.e. against the dancer? the street festival organisation? ...
The good news is that more than ten years of open2.net content has been moved to a new website at open.edu/openlearn, creating one home for all the Open University's free online learning for the public.
The new site continues to support OU-BBC broadcasts, but also gives access to iTunes U podcasts, YouTube videos, free study units taken from OU modules and topical content, arranged under subject areas relating to the OU curriculum.
There's lots to do - you can watch Evan Davis exploring the state of British manufacturing; explore the frozen planet; get to know the science and history of the Olympics or have a look at our study units in LearningSpace.
Any existing links that direct people to open2.net content will automatically send people to the relevant pages on the new site.
You’ll find more information at open.edu/openlearn.
open2.net, formerly the online home of joint Open University and BBC programming, is now closed. The good news is that more than ten years of open2.net content has been moved to a new website at open.edu/openlearn, creating one home for all the Open University's free online learning for the public. The new site continues to support OU-BBC broadcasts, but ...
As part of an expert blog, OU Visiting Research Fellow, Peter Sommer makes three predictions for 2012 related to issues around digital evidence.
This blog brings together all the responses to the call for predictions of developments in 2012 and beyond, whether affecting IT law, IP, data protection, e-disclosure, law firm technology or any number of vaguely related developments. Read the blog on SCL - The IT Law Community.
As part of an expert blog, OU Visiting Research Fellow, Peter Sommer makes three predictions for 2012 related to issues around digital evidence. This blog brings together all the responses to the call for predictions of developments in 2012 and beyond, whether affecting IT law, IP, data protection, e-disclosure, law firm technology or any number of vaguely related developments. ...
A civil appeals court in Aix-en-Provence has awarded €10,000 damages to a wife for having to endure her ex-husband’s sustained lack of sexual interest in her for several years.
The award of compensation for “injurious abstinence” in Monique v Jean-Louis B was made under article 1382 of the French civil code. French law says that married couples undertake to lead a “shared communal life” and the appeals court ruled that this includes reasonable sexual consortium.
Monique, 47, had brought the action following 21 years of marriage which she claimed were sexually unfulfilling. Her husband, 51, defended the allegation by arguing that there was significant sexual liaison albeit intermittent because of his health problems which included chronic fatigue arising from a heavy work schedule.
The court rejected the husband’s case. It stated that a sexual relationship between a husband and wife manifests the affection they have for one another and ruled “in this case it was absent”.
It found that the husband had failed to prove to the court that health problems were the reasons for his continuing abstinence from sex.
Historically, the English church courts would sometimes order a medical examination of a husband to determine whether he had the physical capacity to consummate a marriage. In 1778, for example, in a Canterbury case, penis inspectors were appointed by the court to evaluate the man’s virility.
The medical examination showed that the husband’s manhood (known legally as his “virile member”) was judged to be “soft and short”.
The court, however, noted that such flaccidity “does not always continue” (a man, after all, might not be fully aroused when being inspected by officers of the law) and ordered the marriage to run for three months before judgment could be conclusive.
In England, the matrimonial obligation is to maintain a “mutually tolerable sexual relationship” although even that doesn’t apply across the life of a marriage. The old legalistic maxim that normal frequency of marital sex is “twice a week”, expressed in the delicate maxim bis ruere in hebdomade (to disturb twice in seven) isn’t concrete law.
As the seasoned family law judge Lord Merriman said in a case in 1947 “No one can sit here as long as I have sat without realising that there is the greatest diversity of standards between one set of spouses and another as to what is or is not a normal standard of sexual intercourse”.
In the 1947 case he ruled that a husband who’d been prodigious in his sexual demands “sometimes even as much as five times in one night” and who had also made “certain revolting suggestions” to his wife about alternative sexual practices, was acting unreasonably. The major text on sex law says it would be unreasonable if “a husband insists on sex after every meal”.
In 1960, the Court of Appeal ruled that a wife from Croydon was in breach of her marital obligations when, with great intolerance towards her husband who wasn’t as sexually charged as she was, she repeatedly badgered him for sex.
To rouse him into copulation she would, in the early hours of the morning, “pull his hair, catch hold of him by the ears, and shake his head violently to and fro”.
By always eventually conceding to her demands, however, the husband was judged to have accepted her behaviour. So, no divorce for him – a crash helmet in bed was his only legal option.
Gary Slapper is Global Professor at New York University, Director of New York University in London, and Visiting Professor of Law at The Open University. His latest book More Weird Cases is published by Wildy, Simmonds & Hill
You can follow him on Twitter @garyslapper
Gary Slapper, Visiting Professor of Law at The Open University, reflects on legal cases for compensation when it is claimed there has been a failure to deliver reasonable sexual performance. The French attitude to making love is a matter of renown, but now there is judicial precedent showing that a failure to deliver a reasonable sexual performance over time can result in a ...
Hi,
Firstly if I am asking a question that has been asked numerous times before I apologise and am happy to be pointed in the right direction.
Can anyone recommend/advise some pre-course reading material/texts/websites prior to starting W100.
Thanks in advance :o)
Nici
Hi, Firstly if I am asking a question that has been asked numerous times before I apologise and am happy to be pointed in the right direction. Can anyone recommend/advise some pre-course reading material/texts/websites prior to starting W100. Thanks in advance :o) Nici
Useful links
Today (14 November 2011) is Student Finance Day. With student fees and loans high on the agenda for those considering university, Platform caught up with some prospective students via Twitter to find out how fees have influenced their decision making so far... Name: Mrs Claire Siciliano Age: 27 Location: Welwyn Garden City Have you got A Levels or ...
They include laptops, internships and all-expenses paid trips to New York, South America, Florida, South Africa and Europe and the final ten students in each Award will be invited to attend the Undergraduate of the Year Awards in Canary Wharf, London on April 13, 2012, where the winners will be announced by The Rt Hon Michael Portillo from among the best and most employable students in the country.
There are 12 Awards up for grabs identifying the top undergraduates in IT and Computer Science, Management, Law, Arts and Humanities, Business and Finance, Engineering, Social Sciences, Construction, Engineering and Design, Low Carbon, Accountancy and Economics.
Plus there are two special awards: ‘The Future Business Leader’ Award open to students from any discipline and the ‘First Year’ Award open to undergraduates from any course who have just started their second year.
Enter at the Undergraduate of the Year Awards website
Closing date for entries is 31 January 2012.
There are great prizes up for grabs in the 2012 TARGETjobs Undergraduate of the Year Awards. They include laptops, internships and all-expenses paid trips to New York, South America, Florida, South Africa and Europe and the final ten students in each Award will be invited to attend the Undergraduate of the Year Awards in Canary Wharf, London on April 13, 2012, where the ...
Hi,
I have recently started the module 'starting with Law' I was wondering whether the OU uses Harvard Referencing?
Thanks, Fiona
Hi, I have recently started the module 'starting with Law' I was wondering whether the OU uses Harvard Referencing? Thanks, Fiona
Hi everyone,
Just got word from the OU that my registration for W200 is official, for classes starting 04 February 2012. Something a bit weird, though. In the e-mail, this:
Scheduled to be mailed 20 April 2012 for use 19 May 2012
Does this mean that the first two months are to be done without books? Do we need to buy them ourselves?
Hi everyone, Just got word from the OU that my registration for W200 is official, for classes starting 04 February 2012. Something a bit weird, though. In the e-mail, this: Scheduled to be mailed 20 April 2012 for use 19 May 2012 Does this mean that the first two months are to be done without books? Do we need to buy them ourselves?
New recruit reporting for duty,will be startin in few days time,any pointers..............
New recruit reporting for duty,will be startin in few days time,any pointers..............
Hi folks,
Anyone else in Scotland planning to do the OU LL.B?
Hi folks, Anyone else in Scotland planning to do the OU LL.B?
The Open University’s Knowledge Media Institute (KMi) has developed an innovative new search facility called CORE - COnnecting REpositories - to help academics, researchers and students navigate related papers from across UK Open Access repositories.
Current search systems, such as Google Scholar, used to find academic papers can deny users access to the full article, particularly when subscription fees are required and this often proves a frustration for scholars. CORE specialises in searches of the full-text items held on all approved Open Access repositories, ensuring a vastly improved level of accessibility for users. Anyone searching CORE will therefore receive better access to relevant results. In addition, the CORE system stores these downloads, so that papers are still available even if their original repository is offline, thus ensuring a reliable service.
The creation of CORE – symbolised with an eye-catching apple core logo - was funded by JISC and is accessible via an online portal, mobile devices or through repositories and libraries which have integrated CORE with their own search features. Researchers can be confident they are receiving the most relevant recommendations as the system is the first to offer similar articles based on the full text of papers and currently searches 142 British research repositories and libraries.
Senior Research Fellow at the OU, Zdenek Zdrahal, who led the project, said: “The Open University is at the forefront of producing new and innovative advancements in educational resources. CORE is an exciting addition to this history and we believe it will be beneficial to the academic research community and to the OU. There are plans to develop systems further, to aid research.”
CORE is already integrated into The Open University’s research repository, Open Research Online (ORO) which includes more than 18,900 research publications. It is hoped that CORE will be adopted for use in many other universities and academic institutions.
CORE received £40,000 funding from JISC and the project took place over six months finishing in July 2011. Andrew McGregor, JISC programme manager, said: “UK repositories contain a wealth of high quality research papers. This service should help make it easier for researchers to discover and explore this content. CORE is an exciting demonstration of how JISC’s investment in emerging semantic technologies is being harnessed to benefit researchers.”
Visit the CORE website. A 'how to' video will follow shortly - watch this space!
The Open University’s Knowledge Media Institute (KMi) has developed an innovative new search facility called CORE - COnnecting REpositories - to help academics, researchers and students navigate related papers from across UK Open Access repositories. Current search systems, such as Google Scholar, used to find academic papers can deny users access to the full article, particularly when ...
Speakers for Schools are offering state schools the opportunity to access a fantastic network of speakers who are willing to give inspirational talks to young people for free.
These speakers have kindly agreed to give at least one talk per annum in a state school and will address the big subjects: technological, scientific, political, economic, historical, cultural, artistic, ecological and ethical. They are people who will be able to explain the latest developments in areas such as business, cosmology, biology, medicine, linguistics, history, engineering, inter alia.
Speakers include: Honorary graduates Baroness Tessa Blackstone, Sir Peter Bonfield, Sir Christopher Bland, Sir William Castell, Evan Davis, Sir Richard Lambert and Martha Lane Fox. As well as David Cameron, Nick Clegg, Lord Sebastian Coe and other well know faces.
For further information or to apply for a speaker, visit the Speaker4schools website: http://www.speakers4schools.org/
Speakers for Schools are offering state schools the opportunity to access a fantastic network of speakers who are willing to give inspirational talks to young people for free. These speakers have kindly agreed to give at least one talk per annum in a state school and will address the big subjects: technological, scientific, political, economic, historical, ...
The figure is nearly double that of a year ago – with 70 per cent of visitors now downloading straight to mobile devices.
The BBC reported that the OU is now neck and neck with rival Stanford University, and ahead of universities such as Yale and Oxford.
Martin Bean, Vice-Chancellor of The Open University, said: “Right from the start, the OU has always kept pace with the new technologies of the time and it is fascinating to see the development of the post personal computing stage of the OU on iTunes U.
“It is crucial for part-time students to be able to study when, where and how it suits them and we excel at finding new and better ways to enable students to study on the move.”
The OU is one of the biggest and most popular contributors to iTunes U, averaging 275,000 downloads a week. It regularly appears on the iTunes U Top Charts and has one of the widest ranging libraries, including both audio visual collections, and over 400 eBooks derived from our award winning OpenLearn site.
In July 2011, the OU’s The History of English in Ten Minutes collection which went straight to the iTunes U (UK) chart at number four after just four days. Shakespeare was the top OU download on iTunes U that month.
OU material on iTunes U gets a worldwide audience with 90 per cent of visitors to the site coming from outside the UK. An OU on iTunes U audience survey revealed that 96 per cent use the materials for learning.
The Open University first posted material on iTunes U in June 2008 and recorded 20 million iTunes U downloads in June 2010. In October 2010, the OU was one of the first three universities worldwide to put eBooks onto iTunes U.
The Open University has just hit 40 million downloads on iTunes U which, according to the BBC, makes it a world leader. The figure is nearly double that of a year ago – with 70 per cent of visitors now downloading straight to mobile devices. The BBC reported that the OU is now neck and neck with rival Stanford University, and ahead of universities such as Yale and ...
Can a cat be both alive and dead? Can a computer think? How does a tortoise beat Achilles in a race? To find out watch the brand new OU ITunes U collection entitled ’60-Second Adventures in Thought’. Voiced by comedian David Mitchell, these fast-paced animations explain six famous thought experiments, from the ancient Greeks to Albert Einstein, that ...
Hi everyone, I'm starting this module in November, and just started DD301 this weekend, I live in region 13, who else is starting this next month? :)
Hi everyone, I'm starting this module in November, and just started DD301 this weekend, I live in region 13, who else is starting this next month? :)
Anyone else starting law in November? Thoughts and feelings
Anyone else starting law in November? Thoughts and feelings
Legal Verdict is a new blog offering legal commentary from The Open University’s School of Law.
"Law holds a great deal of interest for many people, whether as an academic discipline, as the foundation of the daily work of legal practitioners or just as a matter of broad social interest. Some of the authors of blogs on this site are legal academics at The Open University and others have kindly agreed to contribute as guest authors. Debate and comment is welcomed so please feel free to post your observations," reads the About page.
Legal Verdict is a new blog offering legal commentary from The Open University’s School of Law. "Law holds a great deal of interest for many people, whether as an academic discipline, as the foundation of the daily work of legal practitioners or just as a matter of broad social interest. Some of the authors of blogs on this site are legal academics at The Open University and ...
Hi i am Adam I am 21 I live in liverpool and i am starting to study my LLB in February i am looking either for a online study buddy or some one i can meet up with in a local libary facetime skype? what ever really.
Can anyone help ?
Thank's Adam
Hi i am Adam I am 21 I live in liverpool and i am starting to study my LLB in February i am looking either for a online study buddy or some one i can meet up with in a local libary facetime skype? what ever really. Can anyone help ? Thank's Adam yes 67% (8 votes) no 33% (4 ...
David Attenborough 55% (399 votes) Mary Beard 5% (33 votes) Martin Lewis 3% (24 votes) Jo Frost 2% (15 votes) Brian Cox 21% (150 votes) Maggie Aderin-Pocock 0% (1 vote) The Hairy Bikers: David Myers & Simon King 2% (18 votes) The Two Fat Ladies: Clarissa ...