By dawn’s early light: Burnham’s recalibration on Europe

It’s nearly summit time and rather than second-guess what’s coming (that’s what BlueSky is for) I want to sketch out what appears to be something between walking back and bailing out by Burnham over the last couple of months.

This was prompted by his speech to the Lord Mayor’s Banquet on Monday evening, which set out his wider thoughts on foreign policy.

The speech was instructive in that Burnham evidently does have both views and a model of the UK’s role in the world, but also that these do not have all that much depth.

His central concept is that values (selfless and noble) and interests (selfish and more venal) are not as in tension as others might have supposed or argued. A quick glance around most states, at most times, would rather question his claim that these are often posed in a false choice: almost everyone argues that their actions are both high-minded and good for themselves.

Any way, this made for a good hook and a way into critiquing foreign policy over the past decade. This highlights the vacillatory and inconstant policy shifting under various governments, from China to the Middle East to the international system writ large.

Easy enough to poke holes in his predecessors’ actions, although again not necessarily very appreciative of the difficulties for any leader to navigate an increasingly unstable environment while also juggling the domestic agenda.

While support Ukraine was one bright light for Burnham, that should be understood as a relatively uncomplex domain, given the primacy of resisting Russian aggression. The other cases he points to as areas where Labour have been making a difference – Middle East, Commonwealth and the EU – read more thinly, focusing on busi-ness rather than the resolution of long-standing and complex tensions. One might also note that China and the US rather drop out from the speech at this point.

All of this then is the contextualisation of Burnham’s EU policy. It’s not simply a side quest or a vehicle for leveraging domestic political situations, but an integral part of a broad thrust of projecting values and enhancing material interests. Which is a big step up from most of the Prime Ministers of the recent period.

This allows Burnham to rehash his critique from the party conference: the status quo doesn’t work for the economy or security and hasn’t delivered on ‘control’.

It also allows him to set up what will be his discursive framing of the summit outcomes: good for people’s pockets, improving on the status quo and sitting within the manifesto red lines.

Except those three ‘tests’ were presented in the reverse order: red lines, then building on the status quo, then the ‘Makerfield test’. This already a more cautious framing than in September’s speech, suggesting a path from here and now to somewhere not that far from here and now.

And so this flows into what he’s now saying about the post-summit agenda.

If September was all about the ‘all options on the table, nudge, nudge’ then this speech was much more ‘we’re going to talk with the EU about what they think and then we’ll talk some more about it’.

This more modest model seemed to get backed up further by interviews Burnham gave on Tuesday saying he’d wait until December to ‘set out options’, and that there was ‘no rush’.

This all sounds like a man who is starting to get to grips with the time and effort involved in translating his (sincere) desire for much closer UK-EU relations into practice.

Everything points to much more willingness on Burnham’s part to invest his political capital into areas such as social care reform or NEETs: there was no sign this week that Alan Milburn’s 10 year plan for the latter was any barrier to the PM, for example.

This all should feel familiar to anyone who’s followed British debate about Europe over the years. Personally, I’ve been thinking back to Tony Blair, another charismatic leader surfing on a bunch of hope for change, who ended up deferring his big EU policy – Euro membership – to act in other parts of his portfolio. He also was an instinctive pro-European who ended up reining in his enthusiasm in his later years as the politics grew more difficult.

All that might be par for the course, but it’s also important to recognise that Burnham risks more immediate blowback if he’s really not going to realise his earlier rhetoric.

This week has also seen the first case I’ve been aware of where ‘EU diplomats’ have been willing to be quoted in press reports questioning whether he’s really shifted the dial. Politico found a number of such people who (reasonably) felt that it wasn’t for the EU to lay out options to the UK for the future, but for the UK to decide what it was trying to do.

This may be the irony of Burnham’s approach.

He recognises the need for something like a consensus – at least that goes beyond one party – and he’s tried not to prejudge what that consensus should be. These things are foundational for the multi-year negotiations that would be necessary for any move beyond the red lines. But it may also be not quite important enough for Burnham to get that ball rolling.

Considering that aspect might turn out to be the most important part of this summit.

This entry was posted in Uncategorised and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *